Ask what is causing the problem.
A room that feels uncomfortable does not establish that the equipment needs replacement. Ask what has been checked and what findings support the recommendation. Distribution, controls, maintenance, and the building itself can influence comfort.
Review equipment fit.
Heating and cooling capacity should match the needs of the building. ASHRAE’s consumer guidance distinguishes equipment efficiency from capacity and cautions against oversizing. Ask how the proposed selection was determined, especially after additions or envelope improvements.
Compare the complete alternatives.
A repair option should explain the identified issue and repair scope. A replacement proposal should identify equipment, controls, removal, supporting duct or electrical changes, drainage, start-up checks, and warranties. Compare those details alongside the price.
Keep operating-cost claims in context.
Future bills depend on weather, use, utility rates, the envelope, and installation as well as the equipment. Ask which assumptions support a cost projection. Review any current incentive separately from the base project decision.

