Who is Erie Home?
The basics first, before the comparison.
Erie Home (formerly Erie Metal Roofs) is a national roofing franchise that specializes in stone-coated metal shingle systems with 50-year transferable warranties. They operate through high-volume door-to-door canvassing and in-home sales presentations.
Where they are strong
What Erie Home does well.
Erie Home strengths
- 50-year transferable warranty on their metal shingle product
- Stone-coated metal is genuinely long-lasting if it fits your home's style
- Nationwide brand recognition
Where Arch City is different
- We offer the same materials at transparent online pricing — no 3-hour in-home sales presentation required
- Our estimate tool gives you a real range in under 2 minutes; Erie requires a scheduled home visit before you see any number
- We don't pressure you. Our field reps arrive for inspection prepared to walk through findings, not a sales script
- We install shingle, TPO, EPDM, and torch-down in addition to metal — most homes don't need a full metal upgrade to get a durable roof
What customers report
Common themes from Erie Home's public reviews.
Sourced from aggregated public reviews (BBB, Google, Trustpilot). Not universal — plenty of customers have positive experiences. These are the themes that recur often enough to be worth knowing before you sit through a sales presentation.
Quotes come in 40-80% higher than local competitors for equivalent work
Sales meetings last 2-4 hours; "today only" discount pressure at the end
Hard to get a written quote without committing to a full presentation
Decision
Who should you actually call?
Erie Home is the right call if you want a national-brand warranty, you're comfortable sitting through a full in-home sales presentation, and you have the budget for premium-tier pricing.
Arch City Builders is the right call if you want a real price range online in 2 minutes, prefer to handle everything on your schedule without a long sales visit, and want a local contractor who meets your insurance adjuster on the roof rather than leaving you to fight the claim alone.
The honest advice: get quotes from both. Compare line items, not just totals. Our estimate tool makes that step free and non-committal — two minutes of typing and you have our number on paper.
Other comparisons
Still shopping? Here's how we stack up against others.
Let’s put your project in motion.
Tell us about your property, your priorities, and the work you have in mind. We will help you identify the next step.